The console argument is completely valid and I say that as someone who has spent an embarrassing amount of money on PC hardware. For pure gaming the value proposition of a console is unambiguous.
Where PC wins is flexibility — I use my rig for work, for creative software, for streaming, for emulation. The cost is spread across multiple use cases. If you're purely gaming a console is the rational choice and I will die on that hill even as a PC person.
Currently running a 4090 and not upgrading until the 6090 or until Nvidia learns what the word 'reasonable' means. Whichever comes first.